CrossFit Medical Society™ Newsletter
October 2024, Issue 4
Low Energy Availability (LEA) - Not Just a Young Athlete Problem
The most missed diagnosis among active mid-life women
Dr. Carla DiGirolamo
Fellow, American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists; Board Certified Reproductive Endocrinologist; Menopause Society Certified Provider; CrossFit Level 1 Trainer; PN1 Certified Nutrition Coach
As a menopause hormonal specialist who focuses on active and high-performing women, I am amazed (and saddened, quite frankly) by how so many women are being misdiagnosed or worse yet, completely blown off by their providers when they seek care for often debilitating symptoms during mid-life.
A typical situation is a menopausal woman in her mid-fifties sees her provider for symptoms of fatigue, poor mental and physical performance, sleep disturbance, mood changes, and a 10 lb weight gain despite “doing nothing differently”. Her provider may or may not do an evaluation and ultimately tells this woman either “You need hormone therapy” or “You’re just getting older”. She then, understandably, gets frustrated because she’s really suffering and doesn’t feel like pills are the answer. She schedules a visit with me and shares that she is a lifelong recreational runner training for the Boston Marathon - on 1200 calories per day. I ask if she shared this information with her provider and she responded “They never asked”.
Scenarios similar to this are apparent in at least half of the active women whom I see for menopausal care. A major player leading to this problem is that the hormonal changes of menopause result in sometimes dramatic changes in body composition, which elicits the “knee-jerk” reaction to train more and eat less, try fad interventions such as “keto” or “intermittent fasting” - all of which further exacerbate the energy imbalance causing her symptoms. There is also not a lot of guidance on how to adjust nutrition to changing activity levels, activity types, injuries, or evolving health issues in the midlife female population.
What is Low Energy Availability (LEA)?
Simply defined, LEA occurs when there is an inadequate amount of energy available (EA) to support vital bodily functions after supplying physical activity/exercise. For the math geeks in the audience, the equation looks like this:
When LEA is prolonged and or severe (Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport: REDs), this can cause metabolic disturbance, injury, bone fractures, loss of or irregular menstrual cycles, sleep disturbance, brain fog, and poor performance among other long-term health issues.
This year, the International Olympic Committee (IOC) released its 2023 Consensus Statement on LEA and Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (REDs). This statement includes an outstanding review of the latest research done on LEA and REDs as it relates to causes, short and long-term impact on the athlete, and describes a very useful tool (IOC REDs CAT2 three-step protocol) for trainers and providers to assess the degree of risk of LEA / REDs and plan interventions.
Below are two (among many) important points from the IOC 2023 Consensus statement:
Inadequate carbohydrate intake is a major contributor to LEA / REDs. The statement cites multiple studies in male and female endurance athletes that show that <3g carbohydrate/kg of body mass was associated with a deleterious impact on bone, immunity, and iron biomarkers and can accelerate the progression of LEA to REDs.
Seminal research in sedentary females identified 30 kcal/kg of fat-free body mass/day as a threshold below which perturbations in sex hormones and changes in bone turn-over markers were seen and that >/= 45 kcal/ kg of fat-free body mass is optimal for maintenance and growth.
It’s important to note that these thresholds were determined in studies of sedentary females, which underscores the even greater caloric needs of active women and competitive/elite athletes.
Symptoms of LEA Look Just Like Symptoms of Perimenopause and Menopause
The overlap between the symptoms of the menopause transition and LEA can be challenging for providers - especially if they don’t ask about the patient’s training and fueling. If they do ask, they may not understand what “adequate” and “inadequate” fueling look like, as this is also a challenge for experts in the fitness industry. For this reason, publications like the IOC Consensus Statement are critically important for healthcare providers and trainers alike.
Symptoms common to LEA, Perimenopause, and Menopause:
Brain fog
Irregular menstrual cycles
Sleep disturbance
Mood disturbance and irritability
Poor mental and physical performance
Lack of motivation
Impact of LEA on the Perimenopausal and Menopausal Woman
LEA has a unique impact on females as compared to males due to the evolutionary design of female hormone physiology to achieve and support pregnancy. This is evidenced by the need for adequate energy and fat composition for the initiation of puberty (reproductive competence) and the loss of menstrual cycles that often occurs when females are in a persistent state of LEA.
During perimenopause and menopause, female physiology is still “wired” to depend heavily on energy availability. However, as menstrual cycles become irregular and ultimately absent, the reproductive hormonal “buffer” wanes and the impact of LEA weighs more heavily on the stress response (Cortisol) system.
When LEA is persistent, activation of the stress response is persistent, which leads to inflammation, potential for injury, poor recovery, possible thyroid disturbance, and fat retention to preserve energy when energy intake is inadequate. This is why fasting > 12 hours shows no greater benefit than sound nutrition strategies that do not involve prolonged fasting and CAN EVEN BE HARMFUL in the non-obese, active, mid-life female population.
Unfortunately, there is little to no study of LEA and REDs specifically in the perimenopausal and menopausal populations, however, the published guidelines noted above can provide a starting point.
Approach to the Mid-life Female Experiencing Symptoms
STEP 1 of the approach to symptoms in perimenopausal and menopausal women is to assess their energy balance! If you are a trainer, coach, or healthcare provider, the first thing to address is her training, physical activity, participation in sport, and her nutrition. The most “average appearing” individual could be a competitive athlete, so ask EVERYONE! A week or 2 of training and food logs can be very helpful for gaining an objective perspective of the client’s energy state.
Carbohydrate management is challenging in midlife women because as hormones change, relative insulin resistance becomes apparent, in part, due to declines in muscle mass and function rendering glucose utilization by skeletal muscle less efficient. As we have learned above, adequate carbohydrate intake is critical for optimal energy balance however, should focus on high-quality carbohydrate sources, minimizing refined sugars, nutrient timing strategies where carbohydrate is available pre-and post-training, and concentrating carbohydrate intake earlier in the day.
Adequate total energy is critical for energy balance, however, adequate macronutrients are also important. For mid-life women, protein intake needs priority as the changing hormones result in catabolism of muscle and bone, particularly in the first few years of menopause. Ensuring sufficient “building blocks” to rebuild muscle following training or physical activity is essential for recovery.
Lastly, the importance of effective recovery cannot be overstated. Because females are particularly sensitive to energy balance and stress response system activation, a comprehensive recovery regimen will help prepare the athlete for subsequent training sessions and avoid injury. Greater attention to warm-up and cool-down, tissue care with massage, foam rolling, mobility work, cold plunges, sauna, sleep, sound nutrition, and mindset work should be part of every training program.
My Training and Nutrition are Optimized, but I’m Still Having Symptoms
There is no doubt that optimal training and nutrition do not solve every symptom of menopause, however, it does lay the foundation for vitality, and longevity and for helping therapeutics work more effectively!
For those symptoms such as hot flashes, vaginal dryness, painful sex, urinary symptoms of menopause - and so many more - many hormonal and non-hormonal treatments are safe and effective. However, when the basic foundations of health are not addressed, the therapeutics alone may not provide the same efficacy of symptom relief.
The key to optimal health, vitality, and longevity requires a “team” approach with coordinated input from experienced fitness and nutrition experts and informed healthcare professionals. This model of women’s healthcare is finally emerging and is certain to be the next revolution in women’s health. Stay tuned!
References
2023 Mountjoy M et al. IOC Consensus Statement on Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (REDs); Br J Sports Med 2023;57:1073–1097. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2023-106994
Next Level: Your Guide to Kicking Ass, Feeling Great, and Crushing Goals Through Menopause and Beyond Paperback – May 17, 2022. by Stacy T. Sims PhD (Author), Selene Yeager (Author)
Provider Spotlight
Written by Dr. Tom McCoy
Athletics were always her outlet whenever life got bumpy, and this only deepened her appreciation for them.
Carla fell in love with sports at an early age. Her father was a semi professional football player and both of her brothers played as well. Athletics were always her outlet whenever life got bumpy, and this only deepened her appreciation for them.
In highschool she decided to level up her commitment and started playing sports. Her Dad explained that because she wasn't that big she was gonna have to hit the gym and lift. Shortly thereafter she found herself power lifting at a local gym in the suburbs of Boston where she was the only teenage girl. The year was 1985. She absolutely loved it and never felt out of place.
She went on to get her MD from Wake Forest University and completed her residency in OB/Gyn at Brown and Fellowship in reproductive endocrinology at Mass General (Harvard). She has been at the same practice in Boston for the last 16 years.
Carla discovered CrossFit in 2015 and in 2017 was a member of the second MDL1 class that took place in Aromas, CA. She describes this as one of the more inspiring experiences of her career. As she describes it, after starting CF at age 45, by age 50 she was the most fit she had ever been.
Today Carla’s passion is to work with women from puberty through menopause to help them realize their full potential in health, performance and vitality. To better support her patients, she also became certified with the North American Menopause Society as a Certified Menopause Practitioner (MSCP) and has developed a deep fund of knowledge in how to support women through all stages of life.
Carla recently moved to Florida to be closer to her son who they just dropped at college last month. Her family moved into their new house on Sunday and she joined her new CrossFit affiliate, CrossFit Pompano Beach, on Tuesday. She plans to transition full time to her private practice focusing on women's health in Jan 2025. If you would like to work with Dr DiGirolamo she is listed on the Directories and is licensed in many states across the country
Student Scholarship Award
Congrats to the first TWO recipients of the CFMS Student Scholarship. Mikayla and Mikinzie Boeder are medical students at the University of Minnesota. Mikayla and Mikinzie have a passion for CrossFit and shared their journeys and the benefits of integrating fitness into their schedules by hosting a CrossFit class at their local box for their colleagues. The goal was to expose future medical professionals to the growing field of CrossFit with hopes that students will be better educated on how to implement fitness and wellness into both their own and their future patient’s lives.
The CFMS Student Scholarship is only possible with the contributions from our providers. Thanks to Shveta & Dinesh Raju as well as Jocelyn Rylee, Mikayla and Mikinzie are now able to get the CrossFit Level 1 with the hopes of coaching more in the future!
Taking Control of Your Health
Last month there was a Round Table in Washington D.C. called “American Health and Nutrition: A Second Opinion.” Health and Nutrition advocates in the US presented to government officials about the troubling state of health in the US. We share this with you in hopes to reiterate that our conviction to fix a broken system is a movement that is gaining momentum throughout the US and the world. We know that the CrossFit Affiliate should be at the center where they can connect with providers, empower their community members, and push forward into the future of medicine with the creation of true health homes.
Both the fitness and healthcare industries are evolving as more people dive into the conversation. We’ll continue to share current events as it relates to our mission and hope it motivates you all to continue to lead from the front.
Don’t forget that the CFMS now has a comprehensive bloodwork panel available to the CrossFit community (currently only in the US). Empowering others to regain control of their healthcare journey means access to tools and resources for the individual. Below is the comprehensive list of biomarkers included. Visit the Biomarker HUB on the website and order yours today.
Testosterone, Free and Total; FSH & LH; Cortisol; Homocysteine; TSH Rfx on abnormal to free T4; Lipoprotein (a); Lipid Panel; SHBG, Serum; DHEA-sulfate; Estradiol; Uric Acid; Complete Metabolic Panel ; Insulin; Hemoglobin a1c; Vitamin D, 25-hydroxy; Vitamin B12+ Folate; Ferritin; CBC with differential/platelet; APO-B; CRP
Noteworthy News
-
An important mission for the CFMS is to grow the number of providers on the international directories.
Update on what credentials are needed to be listed:
A total of 10 CME/CEU credits OR a CrossFit Course is now accepted.
This means that providers can complete 10 hours of CME or CEU credits instead of having to go to a CrossFit Course. How can a provider earn 10 credits?
Join the CFMS and complete the already available CME credits
Select an online course from the CrossFit EDU platform (CrossFit Nutrition, etc).
-
Are you going to the Affiliate Summit in Austin? We are! And we want to connect and hear about the work you're doing in your affiliate or clinic. Shoot us an email if you'll be there.
-
Join Dr. Carla for an inspiring and innovative talk on LEA and the Female Athlete.
Register HERE.
-
Coaches Congress is collaborating with the CrossFit Medical Society and CrossFit DACH for their next event in Berlin.
This past weekend the Coaches Congress Crew met in London for a dynamic international event.
All those interested in attending the Berlin event can register for 50% through October 15. 2024 using this LINK
Podcasts and Information
Last month Dr. Christina Migliara led an inspiring Grand Rounds on not only mental health, but how she has curated a Health Home in her affiliate. Under one roof, she provides her members access to mental health support, physical therapy, chiropractic care, and nutrition. Take some time and watch! Reminder: Healthcare providers can submit for 1 ACCME CME Credit. Additionally, Mike Giardina sat down with Best Hour Of Their Day for an insightful discussion on how fitness continues to revolutionize healthcare.